This is a guest post by Cynthia Kocialski, who is the founder of three tech startups. In the past 15 years, she has been involved in dozens of startups. Cynthia writes the Start-up Entrepreneurs’ Blog and has written the book, “Startup from the Ground Up — Practical Insights for Entrepreneurs, How to Go from an Idea to New Business“.
Everything in business is a learning process and advertising is no exception. Advertising promises to reach new potential customers or create an image for your company in the marketplace. What happens when the results don’t meet your expectations, you think back about where things went wrong.
Trust but Verify
Often advertisers will try to sell you ad space based upon the size of their audience, the geographic area of distribution, the frequency of publication, and so forth. This kind of information tells you nothing about their effectiveness for reaching your audience.
A good approach is to find previously published advertising material and check with the companies that advertised (even if the publication provides references). If you ‘re considering placing an ad in a tradeshow program guide, obtain last year’s guide and call the companies that advertised to learn what their results were.
Media salespeople always want to sell long-term contracts. Bulk purchasing is only good if you can use the entire package. Even if the discount is great, avoid such contracts until you know whether the channel works.
Gauge the Appropriateness of the Media
Check out who their advertisers are now. Have you ever noticed that ads on highway billboards and public bus panel are always the major players in some industry? How many local businesses advertise on a highway billboard? How many are instead Ford, Toyota, IBM, Microsoft, and Apple? There is a reason: these channels are very expensive and cost prohibitive to small companies.
Note when competitors or similar industries are running their promotions. They have a lot of experience advertising to the same audience and know best when to reach the targeted customer. Car dealers know to advertise late in a week because most people buy cars on weekends. Weight loss programs don’t advertise late in a week because no one wants to start a diet on Friday. Watch your email box. When do you receive notices about online store offers, newsletters, or notices about tradeshows?
A medical clinic and day spa service business advertised in the local newspapers and through email marketing. The clinic tried each of these approaches for a year or more before they disappeared from both media. Look back at previous advertisers and see what they did; it’s an indication of how well the media worked for them.
Media Buyer Beware of Free
If readers get something free, it’s not as effective for advertising as a publication with paid readers. All trade and newspapers want to tell you about how many readers they have, but many give away their publications. The readers don’t necessarily look at or read such publications.
My local town newspaper boasts a large circulation because it is mailed without charge it to all businesses and everyone’s houses. Likewise, many online information sites have free email newsletters, but that doesn’t mean the recipients read the newsletters. Similarly, organizations will report that a percentage of their membership rolls have particular demographics, but it doesn’t follow that those members have paid for those memberships. Some organizations offer free memberships to certain individuals just to be able to use them to promote the group for advertising rates and some consider those who signed up for the free newsletter or notifications to be members. Advertising rates reflect the audience size, more people means higher rates.
How Not to Compete with the Large Companies for Attention
Large companies tend to advertise in the largest reaching media. They will place ads in The Wall Street Journal or Time magazine, but not in local or regional publications. They will advertise on the largest websites, but not the smaller ones. It’s easier and more manageable for them to deal with national media organizations than a gaggle of small, niche, or local media companies. By contrast, targeted and niche marketing works best for startups, which have a limited budget. It’s better to dominate a subset of customers in a niche market or a locality and to be pervasively known within the niche than it is to build a little awareness everywhere.
Whenever the target audience has a lot of choices, it’s difficult to pinpoint the most promising ones. It’s harder to be effective in TV than in radio. In television, viewers are loyal to a program, not to a network. Most viewers have access to hundreds of channels and flip between them looking for an interesting show to watch. With radio, listeners usually have their favorite three stations and change between these few.
The concepts of frequency and reach apply equally to newspapers, television, radio, or the Internet. It’s more effective to dominate a time slot or customer segment. Instead of using the shotgun approach and advertising in twenty-five magazines, advertise in a few and give the appearance of being a national brand to that customer segment.
Advertising Strategy must be Consistent with Pricing
Consider the following real business examples. The average selling price of one startup’s product was $1,200, but the advertising cost to obtain a single lead was over $300. Competitors’ pricing was $1,800 and they were spending less than $156 to obtain an actual customer. That’s a big difference between obtaining a lead and actually closing on a sale. By contrast, if the product price is $25,000 and the advertising cost to obtain a lead was $200, then the producer may have a viable marketing strategy. The key to a viable strategy lies in the advertising cost per lead and advertising cost to obtain a sale, not in the size of the overall advertising budget. When choosing a promotion approach, consider whether it can be sustained long enough to prove the assumptions and whether if it fails, there is enough budget left to try a different approach.
Internet
Bring up the topic of pay-per-click (PPC) at any meeting about advertising, and you’ll hear immediate groans all around you. It doesn’t matter if you are talking about Google or Facebook ads. Also, bidding costs can be prohibitively high for many new businesses. Everyone, particularly startups, has spent large sums trying to figure out which keywords work best. And keeping page one ranking is often as expensive as per-per-click advertising. I was at a Constant Contact seminar recently, and the speaker said that the company spends $4 million of PPC and another $4 million on maintaining page one ranking. The company has $128 million in sales and just this type of advertising is over 6% of revenue. A common misconception is that the Internet is free, but effectiveness on the Internet is as expensive as in any traditional media. All media present their challenges.
DIY Approach is Usually More Costly
An agency or a media buyer will be expensive and most won’t even handle small companies, but despite the costs, it’s still less expensive than the DIY method. The reason is because they will be able to “ramp up” faster than you can without them. Agencies have many clients and are paid on commissions for the media buys. They are not going to get you better pricing, but they can get better positioning for your ads as well as help you with changing the original contract if the ads don’t work as expected. Advertising is an art. Even an agency will need to experiment with your product and company, and this is both a time consuming and costly trial and error process.
When dealing with an agency, startups need to be very proactive. They need to track the results diligently and feed them back to the agency. What worked well five years ago may not get results today, and what worked for a similar product might not work for yours.
Advertising is about Trade-Offs and Effectiveness
Effective advertising can only be achieved through experimentation. Advertising always seems too expensive and too slow at getting the desired results, but there’s no way around these unfortunate facts. It’s not just the cost of the media buys but also the cost of experimenting with the various channels, determining which one works best, and discovering how to optimize the performance of each channel. The selection of a publication is important, but so are where you place the ad, the size, the color scheme, the wording, and the competitors for the audience’s attention. You could place your ad in the right journal yet get little or no response. On the other hand, the perfect ad may not resonant with the audience because it’s in the wrong publication.
There is no right answer; many approaches can achieve the same results. It is, however, a zero sum game. Location is a good example. A location, either storefront or tradeshow floor position, can give a startup more visibility with passer-by traffic. With more visibility, less can be spent on paid advertising to get customers to the location. Likewise, there can be trade-offs between advertising versus labor and travel costs associated with direct marketing and sales.
(photo by lorenkerns, on Flickr)